Brant County's IT Service ProviderAdvertisement

Crossing the floor: a short history of MPs who switched sides — and what it would mean here

In the last two weeks of this campaign, one rumour got more attention than almost anything else: that the winning candidate might cross the floor, and the vote would mean nothing.

It is not a new fear. It is not a new idea, either. But it is worth separating what is possible from what is likely — and from what has actually happened before.

What “crossing the floor” means

The House of Commons is built like a face-off: government on one side, opposition on the other, with a wide aisle between them. “Crossing the floor” means exactly what it sounds like: an MP leaves the party they were elected under and joins another one. They keep their seat. There is no recall election. The voters are not asked.

It can also mean leaving a party to sit as an Independent, or being kicked out of a caucus. It happens for reasons that range from principle — a policy disagreement too big to swallow — to pure opportunism: a job offer, a better shot at re-election, a grudge against a leader.

Why it is legal — and what it would take to ban it

There is no law against it. None. When you vote, you vote for a person, not a party, and the seat belongs to that person under Canada’s parliamentary system. The party doesn’t own the seat, and neither do the voters, legally speaking — however much it might feel otherwise.

That surprises a lot of people, and MPs have tried to change it. Bills in 2008 and 2009 would have forced an MP who crossed to sit as an Independent or resign and run in a byelection under their new banner. They died on the Order Paper.

It keeps failing for a basic reason: the system is built on the idea that an MP must be free to change their mind. A law against crossing could trap an MP in a party they no longer believe in, and it would put judges in the position of deciding when a change of mind is legitimate. Most MPs, of any party, don’t want that.

The big crossings

1917 — Conscription. During the First World War, Liberal MPs crossed to join Robert Borden’s Unionist government over conscription, splitting the Liberal party for a generation.

1990 — The Bloc is born. Lucien Bouchard, a cabinet minister in Brian Mulroney’s government, resigned and crossed the floor to sit as an Independent, then formed the Bloc Québécois. Seven more Conservatives and one Liberal joined him. It changed the country.

2003 — A merger too far. Scott Brison, a Progressive Conservative MP, crossed to the Liberals rather than join the new Conservative Party when the Progressive Conservatives merged with the Canadian Alliance.

2005 — The vote that saved a government. Belinda Stronach, a Conservative MP from Ontario, crossed to the Liberals and joined Paul Martin’s cabinet. Her vote saved the government in a confidence vote — by one.

2006 — Two weeks after the election. David Emerson was elected as a Liberal, then crossed to Stephen Harper’s Conservatives before he was even sworn in, taking a cabinet post. He later wrote that he crossed because he wanted to be in the government of the day, not in opposition.

2021 — The exception. Jenica Atwin left the Greens for the Liberals and won re-election in her riding. Floor crossers rarely win their next election, but Atwin did.

What usually happens to crossers at the next election

Not well, lately. Semra Sevi, a political scientist at the University of Toronto, tracked every MP who switched parties between 1950 and 2014. She found that most crossers don’t survive their next election. They are usually punished by voters, and many retire rather than face it.

Voters often read a switch as opportunistic, and they punish it. Eve Adams never even got to run: after crossing from the Conservatives to the Liberals in 2015, she lost the Liberal nomination in her riding.

Right now in Ottawa

Floor crossing is not ancient history — it decided who governs Canada this year. After the April 2025 election, the Liberals were one seat short of a majority. Three Conservative MPs — Anthony Rota, Chris d’Entremont and Michael Ma — crossed to the Liberals. The government that took office with a minority now governs with a majority, without a single vote being cast.

As of the House of Commons’ own standings page, checked November 21, 2026, the Liberals hold 173 seats, the Conservatives at 137, the Bloc at 21, the NDP at 5, the Greens at 1, and six seats vacant. A government that won 169 seats at the ballot box became a majority without a general election in between. That is why people argue about it: to its defenders, each MP made a free choice; to its critics, voters were never asked.

The byelections since 2025 — who had the seat, who won it

Thirteen seats have come open since the April 2025 election. Seven have been filled already; six more are decided on December 7, including ours.

Already decided:

  • Battle River—Crowfoot (Aug 18, 2025): Conservative held it, Conservative won it — Pierre Poilievre took the seat Damien Kurek gave up for him.
  • University—Rosedale (Apr 13, 2026): Liberal held it, Liberal won it — Danielle Martin replaced Chrystia Freeland.
  • Scarborough Southwest (Apr 13, 2026): Liberal held it, Liberal won it — Doly Begum replaced Bill Blair.
  • Terrebonne (Apr 13, 2026): Liberal held it, Liberal won it — Tatiana Auguste won the rematch after the court annulled her one-vote win.
  • North Vancouver—Capilano (Aug 31, 2026): Liberal held it, Liberal won it — Braeden Caley replaced Jonathan Wilkinson.
  • Chicoutimi—Le Fjord (Aug 31, 2026): Conservative held it, Liberal won it — Daniel Gobeil took Richard Martel’s seat. The only one of the seven to change hands.
  • Beaches—East York (Aug 31, 2026): Liberal held it, Liberal won it — Tanveer Shahnawaz replaced Nate Erskine-Smith.

Decided December 7 — who held them:

  • Brantford—Brant South: Conservative (Larry Brock).
  • Laurier—Sainte-Marie: Liberal (Steven Guilbeault).
  • Rosemont—La Petite-Patrie: NDP (Alexandre Boulerice).
  • Saint-Hyacinthe—Bagot—Acton: Bloc Québécois (Simon-Pierre Savard-Tremblay).
  • Scarborough North: Liberal (Shaun Chen).
  • Yorkton—Melville: Conservative (Cathay Wagantall).

Six of the seven already decided stayed with the party that held them. December 7 will tell whether that holds.

What it would mean here

This riding knows the story first-hand. The seat is empty because Larry Brock, the Conservative MP here, resigned on September 18 to return to work as a lawyer, leaving Brantford—Brant South without an MP. That was the reason for this byelection, not the rumour about crossing.

And the rumour has already landed here. A supporter joked in a comment on one of Dave Carrol’s posts that Carrol would “cross the floor” if elected. Carrol replied that he is “not crossing the floor,” and that he “made a choice.” It was a joke, but it took hold: more than one voter has asked the question seriously since.

Here is the part worth knowing before you vote on December 7. Whoever wins this seat will hold it until the next federal election, and no one can stop them crossing if they choose to. The ballots are cast for a person, not a party. That is the law. But if the winner crosses, there is a long record of what voters do about it next time — and it is not kind.

Sources

more posts:
2026 By-Election
John Monkhouse

Upcoming Live Talk: Kathryn Kissinger (Green Party) on BrantVotes

Join host John Monkhouse on BrantVotes: The Podcast for a live conversation with Kathryn Kissinger from the Green Party as she shares her perspectives, priorities, and vision for our community. 📌 Event Details 💬 Have Questions? Drop Them in the Comments! Want to hear Kathryn’s take on a specific issue or topic? Drop your questions in the comments below or in the live chat when we go live, and we’ll look to bring them into the conversation! 📺 Mark your calendar and tune in live on Friday, November 20th

Read More »
County of Brant News
John Monkhouse

Packed room in St. George: neighbours weigh in on the 22-unit apartment proposed for 74 High Street

The open house was tonight, Thursday, November 19, 6:00–8:00 p.m., at Gaukel Memorial Community Centre in St. George. It was a packed room, downstairs in the arena meeting room, and there were some great conversations going on. This is a recap of what was on the boards — the proposal is still just a proposal, and the next step is a statutory public meeting. What is proposed The proposal is for a 4-storey (13.0 metres), 22-unit apartment at 74 High Street — six one-bedroom and sixteen two-bedroom units. 35

Read More »
County of Brant News
John Monkhouse

22-unit apartment proposed for 74 High Street, St. George — open house Nov. 19

22-unit apartment proposed for 74 High Street, St. George — open house Nov. 19 Neighbours in St. George have received a letter from GSP Group about a proposed apartment building at 74 High Street, and an open house to discuss it before a formal zoning application is submitted. The open house Thursday, November 19, 2026, 6:00–8:00 p.m. (drop-in) Community Room, Gaukel Memorial Community Centre, 7 Gaukel Drive, St. George Contact: Ethan Cleugh, Planner, GSP Group Inc., 289-778-1429, ecleugh@gspgroup.ca What is proposed Four-storey (13 metre / 43 foot), 22-unit residential

Read More »
Local Federal News
John Monkhouse

Brantford—Brant South by-election: the week in review — November 19, 2026

The fourth week of the Brantford—Brant South federal by-election campaign is in the books, and the field is now final at nine candidates. Anthony Tarrant was confirmed as the People’s Party candidate on Tuesday, November 17 — the ninth name on the ballot — and Elections Canada published the full confirmed list on Wednesday, November 18, unchanged since. Nominations closed at 2:00 p.m. on Monday, November 16. The Daily Ward’s Issue 34, out Wednesday, put five questions to all nine candidates, and seven answered. Here is what each candidate

Read More »
Brant engage
John Monkhouse

Help shape Scotland’s outdoor recreation space — open house November 19

Something new could be taking shape in Scotland. The County of Brant is exploring plans to create a reimagined outdoor recreation space there, with an accessible walking trail, potential biking and recreation features, and improved landscaping. The idea is to formalize the trails so the space works better for walking, biking and other outdoor recreation, and to make it a more welcoming and accessible community space. What it will do The County is developing a draft concept for the space — an accessible walking trail, other potential recreational amenities,

Read More »
Brant engage
John Monkhouse

Electrification, explained: County looks at switching from gas and diesel to electricity as Community Energy Plan takes shape

The County of Brant is explaining another piece of its Community Energy Plan — this time, electrification. Electrification means switching equipment and vehicles that run on gasoline, diesel or natural gas to alternatives powered by electricity. The County’s examples: driving an electric vehicle instead of a gasoline-powered one, using an electric heat pump instead of a gas furnace, and switching certain types of fuel-powered equipment to electric options. The County notes electrification can help reduce greenhouse gas emissions, depending on how electricity is generated and used — and that

Read More »
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x